The Art of Switching Off: Why Holidays Alone Don't Restore You

In short

Holidays restore you, but only briefly: in studies, the effect has usually worn off within one to four weeks back at work. How rested you are depends less on how long you are away than on four experiences: switching off mentally, relaxing, mastering something new and deciding for yourself. So build recovery into every week instead of saving it up.

AI-generated explainer by CHW-Coaching, in German: «Muss man sich nach Feierabend zusammenreissen?» (YouTube Short)

Holidays restore you, but the effect does not last long: in studies, it has usually worn off within one to four weeks back at work (de Bloom and colleagues, 2013; Kühnel and Sonnentag, 2011). How rested you come back depends less on the length of your holiday than on four experiences described by the work psychologists Sabine Sonnentag and Charlotte Fritz (Sonnentag and Fritz, 2007). Here you will find out what they are and how to bring them into your everyday life, not just into your holidays.

Perhaps you know the feeling: “I just need two weeks away right now.” And then, three days back in the office: “Strange, the recovery has already worn off.” Recovery research dampens our great hopes for the holidays a little – and at the same time makes them more realistic. Because recovery works differently from what most people think.

The fade-out effect: recovery has an expiry date

The researcher Jessica de Bloom has studied holiday effects for years. In one of her studies she followed 54 employees through summer holidays that lasted 23 days on average. Health and well-being rose quickly during the holiday and peaked around the eighth day. After their return, they were back at their pre-holiday level within the first week at work (de Bloom and colleagues, 2013). In a study of 131 teachers, the benefits lasted a little longer but had also faded within a month (Kühnel and Sonnentag, 2011). Researchers call this the fade-out effect. Holidays work like sleep: they restore you, but you can’t stockpile them.

What barely matters is interesting too: in de Bloom’s study, the length of the holiday was only weakly linked to how rested someone came back. Enjoyment, relaxation, the feeling of deciding about your own time and good sleep mattered far more. Because the effect fades quickly anyway, there is a good case for spreading recovery across the year: several shorter breaks rather than one single long holiday.

Worth putting in perspective: holidays are recovery, not treatment. For someone who has been exhausted for months, no beach however beautiful will be enough on its own – holidays don’t cure burnout. If the exhaustion has lasted for weeks, your family doctor is the first point of contact; coaching is not therapy and does not diagnose. How to spot serious exhaustion early is covered in the article early signs of burnout. What burnout actually is, I explain in What is burnout?.

The four recovery experiences: what recovery is really made of

If duration isn’t what matters – what does? In 2007, Sabine Sonnentag and Charlotte Fritz described four experiences from which recovery arises. Their model is still the standard in recovery research; a meta-analysis of 54 samples with more than 26,000 people later brought the findings together (Bennett, Bakker and Field, 2018).

  • Detachment: being genuinely away from work in your head – not just physically.
  • Relaxation: states with little tension and a pleasant mood – reading, bathing, lying in a hammock.
  • Mastery: meeting challenges away from work – learning a language, climbing a mountain, attempting a new recipe.
  • Control: deciding for yourself what you do and when.

Two things about this surprise most people. First: against fatigue, switching off mentally helps most. In the meta-analysis by Bennett and colleagues, it was more strongly linked to lower fatigue than relaxation or control; for new energy, on the other hand, the feeling of control mattered most. A second meta-analysis, by Johannes Wendsche and Andrea Lohmann-Haislah, pooled 23 study results covering around 7,000 employees and found a moderate link: people who detach better from work are less exhausted (Wendsche and Lohmann-Haislah, 2017). Someone lying by the pool answering emails in their head barely recovers at all.

Second: switching off doesn’t only mean doing nothing. Mastery experiences – things that challenge you and let you learn something new – are also one of the four sources of recovery. A walking holiday with summits to reach can be more restorative than two weeks in a deckchair, if it detaches you mentally from work completely. Then again, lazing about is allowed too: in de Bloom’s holiday study, passive activities, savouring and relaxation were linked to better recovery. What matters is what does you good.

Small breaks, measurable effect

Recovery doesn’t only happen on holiday – fortunately. A meta-analysis by Patricia Albulescu and colleagues pooled 22 samples with around 2,300 participants. Their finding: even micro-breaks of a few minutes make people a little more vigorous and less fatigued, with small effects; the benefit for performance is less clear (Albulescu and colleagues, 2022). That’s no substitute for a holiday, but it’s a building block that makes every working day more bearable. How to build such breaks in concretely is covered in the article on micro-breaks at work.

Practical rules for really switching off

So what does this mean for your next holiday and for your evenings? A few rules that follow directly from the research:

  • Limit your availability. Switching off starts with work not being able to reach you. Deactivate work email accounts on your phone, set up an out-of-office message with a clear stand-in – and if you must, define one single narrow time window instead of checking “just quickly” on the side. Endless scrolling through the news in the evening also keeps your mind busy; how to get out of it is covered in how to stop doomscrolling.
  • Plan for mastery, not just the deckchair. Ask yourself before the holiday: what do I want to be able to do, experience or achieve that has nothing to do with my work? A diving course, a hike over a mountain pass, a book project – the main thing is that it takes your full attention.
  • Keep control for yourself. Don’t plan out every day of the holiday. The feeling of deciding for yourself is a source of recovery in its own right – and even with family, there may be time windows that belong to you.
  • Land gently. If you jump straight into a mountain of work after the holiday, the recovery fades faster (Kühnel and Sonnentag, 2011). If you can, plan the first few days back on the lighter side.
  • Take the recovery home with you. People who keep experiencing relaxation in their free time after the holiday hold on to its benefits for longer (ibid.). So carry on with what did you good on holiday: the morning swim, reading in the evening, the screen-free Sunday. It wasn’t the place that restored you but what you did there – and much of it works at home too.

If you would like to gauge how much stress is weighing on you at the moment, the free stress test (DASS-21) gives you a first indication. It has 21 statements and does not replace a diagnosis.

Conclusion

Holidays work, but they work briefly: the recovery effect fades within one to four weeks, and the length of the trip matters less than many people think. What counts is quality – genuine mental detachment, relaxation, mastery experiences and the feeling of deciding for yourself. The art of switching off lies in not concentrating recovery into two weeks a year, but anchoring it in holidays and everyday life alike.

When you can no longer switch off

Sometimes knowing all this is not enough, because work simply won’t stop running in your head. In coaching when you can no longer switch off, we look together at which of the four recovery experiences are falling short in your life – and how to build them firmly into your weeks.

Wooden dock on a clear lake

If you would rather not tackle this alone: I am Winn Chelini, a life coach in Wetzikon in the Zurich Oberland. I work in person in Wetzikon or online, in English and German. The first step is a free introductory call of about 20 minutes by Zoom or phone.

Free introductory session

Frequently asked questions

Why do I feel exhausted again so soon after a holiday?

That is the fade-out effect. In one study by Jessica de Bloom, health and well-being were back at their pre-holiday level within the first week at work; in a study of teachers, the benefits had gone within a month. A heavy workload straight after your return speeds this up. Relaxation in your free time afterwards slows it down.

How long does a holiday need to be to restore you?

Length matters less than many people think. In de Bloom's study it was only weakly linked to recovery, and well-being peaked around the eighth day of the holiday. Enjoyment, relaxation, control over your own time and good sleep mattered more. Because the effect fades quickly, there is a good case for spreading recovery across the year.

How do I learn to switch off after work?

Draw a clear line: no work email on your personal phone, and a fixed ritual at the end of the working day, such as a short walk. Look for activities that need your full attention, like sport, music or cooking. And plan time that only you decide about. Switching off mentally is the experience most strongly linked to less fatigue.

What does detachment mean in recovery research?

Detachment means switching off mentally: not thinking about work in your free time, rather than just being physically away. It is one of the four recovery experiences described by Sonnentag and Fritz. A meta-analysis covering around 7,000 employees found a moderate link: people who detach better from work are less exhausted.

Can a holiday cure burnout?

No. A holiday is recovery, not treatment, and two weeks on a beach will not undo months of exhaustion. If the exhaustion has lasted for weeks or you are sleeping badly, your family doctor is the first point of contact. Coaching is not therapy and does not diagnose, but it can support you in reshaping your everyday life.

Sources

  1. Sonnentag, S., & Fritz, C. (2007). The Recovery Experience Questionnaire: Development and validation of a measure for assessing recuperation and unwinding from work. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 12(3), 204–221.
  2. Bennett, A. A., Bakker, A. B., & Field, J. G. (2018). Recovery from work-related effort: A meta-analysis. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 39(3), 262–275.
  3. Wendsche, J., & Lohmann-Haislah, A. (2017). A meta-analysis on antecedents and outcomes of detachment from work. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, 2072.
  4. de Bloom, J., Geurts, S. A. E., & Kompier, M. A. J. (2013). Vacation (after-) effects on employee health and well-being, and the role of vacation activities, experiences and sleep. Journal of Happiness Studies, 14(2), 613–633.
  5. Kühnel, J., & Sonnentag, S. (2011). How long do you benefit from vacation? A closer look at the fade-out of vacation effects. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 32(1), 125–143.
  6. Albulescu, P., Macsinga, I., Rusu, A., Sulea, C., Bodnaru, A., & Tulbure, B. T. (2022). “Give me a break!” A systematic review and meta-analysis on the efficacy of micro-breaks for increasing well-being and performance. PLOS ONE, 17(8), e0272460.